The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Episodes
822 episodes
Mastering Contact Rates: How to Double Your Insurance Sales
P&C agency owner sales strategy for doubling contact rates.We break down the recent hurdles affecting insurance agency growth from lead audits to iOS and Android call screening changes. This episode covers how to manage your outboun...
10% Lead Success? Here's What You're Missing
P&C agency owners can scale agency growth by shifting from emotional lead management to a disciplined operational process.We break down a meta-analysis of 10 million dials to reveal why lead generation results vary wildly between ag...
Why 70% of Agency Turnover Is Emotional, Not Financial with IDudes Mailbag
Stop the revolving door in your office by understanding why P&C insurance agency turnover is actually emotional, not financial.We break down the reality of producer retention and the hidden costs of a chaotic work environment. This ...
Why Your Team Isn’t Closing And How to Fix It with Rhiannon Ward
Rhiannon Ward, owner of Phipps Insurance Agency, is building more than just a business, she’s creating impact by giving back to her community through the Allstate Foundation Helping Hands grant.In this episode, we break down why most tea...
Mastering Sales, Technology & Business Success with Michelle O’Connor
We had the pleasure of sitting down with Michelle O’Connor, a seasoned insurance professional with over 25 years of experience, to talk about the ins and outs of growing a successful business. From mastering follow-ups and building consistent s...
The Skills No One Teaches, But Everyone Needs With Laurie Moroco
Laurie Moroco is a leadership coach and speaker who helps women build confidence, communicate powerfully, and make bold decisions, because extraordinary lives begin with the courage to take action.In this episode, we unpack the real skil...
What Drives Business Growth in the Real World With Bill Snow
Bill Snow, mergers & acquisitions professional and author of Mergers & Acquisitions For Dummies, shares practical insights on business, marketing, and deal-making.In this episode, we break down what really matters, why execution ...
Execution, Niches & AI in Business With Kirk Chester
We’re honored to sit down with Kirk Chester, Principal Broker at Grit Insurance Group. He shares practical insights on building and scaling a business. Specializing in blue-collar industries across multiple states, Kirk focuses on tailored solu...
Building a High-Performance Team with Beau Vincent
Beau Vincent, an insurance agency owner, leadership coach, speaker, and host of ‘The Conviction of a Leader’ podcast, joins the conversation to share the leadership mindset behind building a high-performing business. After growing Vincent Famil...
The Modern Insurance Sales System: Cold Email, Data & Automation with Dean Bowen
In this episode, we sit down with Dean Bowen from Patriotic Insurance Group. He shares how he transitioned from blue-collar work into insurance and built a modern prospecting system using cold email, automation, and data. In this episode, he di...
Breaking Fear-Based Cultures in Business with Brendan Keegan
Brendan Keegan, a 6-time CEO and bestselling author known for scaling companies through transformational growth, shares insights on leadership, career development, and building resilient teams in a changing workplace.The conversation exp...
Finding And Keeping The Best Agents with IDudes Mailbag
How do you really know if someone will succeed as a producer before you hire them? In this Mailbag episode, we discuss the real traits that separate average producers from the ones who consistently perform, stay longer, and fit the culture....
From Hiring Nightmares to Hiring Heroes: The 5-Step Hiring System That Works with IDudes Mail Bag
Hiring doesn’t have to feel like a gamble. In this Mailbag episode, we break down a simple 5-step hiring framework designed to remove guesswork, reduce unknowns, and help you consistently find the right people faster. We walk ...
Catastrophe Insurance, AI Reality & Underwriting Discipline with Terrence McLean
In this episode, we explore the real mechanics behind catastrophe insurance, how underwriting discipline, reinsurance strategy, pricing cycles, and regulatory constraints shape the market more than hype or headlines. Featuring insights from Sag...
Outwork to Win: Leadership, Automation & Building Scalable Success Featuring Jack Wingate
In this episode, we sit down with Jack Wingate, an experienced small business owner and strategic leader, to unpack what truly drives long-term success in today’s competitive business world. From outworking the competition and building discipli...
How Great Leaders Build Winning Teams With Seth Preus
In this insightful episode, we sit down with an entrepreneur, sales strategist, and creator of Racing Snail and Leaderboard Legends, Seth Preus. We explore leadership, motivation, sales productivity, accountability, and performance psychology. ...
Consistency, Leadership, and Scalable Growth in Insurance with Sheppard Bowen
In this episode, we are honored to sit with Sheppard Bowen, co-founder of EVER.PARTY and a former Farmers Insurance agency owner to talk about what actually drives long-term success in the insurance business. From consistency and lead generatio...
The Smarter Way to Market Insurance in a Digital World With Justin Thomas
In this episode, we talk with Justin Thomas about how insurance agents can use digital advertising and funnels to create consistent, high-quality conversations without chasing cold leads. Justin shares his journey from insurance to building Ins...
The Real Business Of Insurance With Jason Levine
In this episode, we’re joined by Jason Levine for a candid conversation about building, growing, and sustaining an insurance agency in an ever-changing market. Jason shares how his path into insurance wasn’t planned, from early ambitions in avi...
The True Cost of Being Underinsured with Eric Brown
In this episode, we sit down with Eric, Accredited Accident Reconstructionist, Ohio Peace Officer, Marine Corps veteran, and founder of Crash Tech Reconstruction Services, to discuss the real-world risks of car accidents and the staggering cost...
Modern Insurance Agencies: Growth, Culture & Leadership with Kelly Donahue
Kelly Donahue, a public speaker and consultant with over a decade of experience in the local insurance agency space, joins Insurance Dudes to break down what it really takes to build a profitable, future-ready insurance agency. The conve...
Redefining Wildfire Insurance: AI, MGA Solutions & Protecting At-Risk
In this episode, Kevin Stein, founder and CEO of Delos Insurance Solutions, shares how he is transforming wildfire insurance through cutting-edge AI and innovative MGA structures. With an aerospace background and advanced degrees from Stanford ...
The Power of Presence in Insurance Claims with Galen Hair
In this episode, we sit down with Galen Hair, founder of Insurance Claim HQ, to uncover the human side of insurance claims. With over 25 years of experience recovering over $1 billion for policyholders across the U.S., Galen shares how empathy,...
Why Agencies Stop Growing And How Real Marketing Fixes It With Andy Neary
In this episode, we uncover the real reasons most insurance agencies struggle to grow and why relying on old-school sales tactics is no longer enough. We’re joined by Andy Neary, who shares how he rebuilt his career from scratch in a market whe...
Real Talk on Success, Mindset & Content With Dan Garzella
In this episode, we’re joined by Dan Garzella, a highly respected entrepreneur and the founder of The Garzella Group, one of the fastest-growing independent insurance agencies in the U.S. Dan has built multiple successful businesses, mentors le...